Consumer group says Big Tech's EU compliance is performative
BEUC tells Brussels that major tech firms' compliance with EU market rules is performative and urges tougher penalties over switching and data control barriers.
According to The Register, the consumer group BEUC says the way large technology companies respond to EU market rules is performative, meaning it looks like compliance without delivering real change for users. The group has made its case directly to Brussels.
BEUC is urging EU authorities to impose tougher penalties on firms it says are putting up barriers that make it harder for people to switch to a rival service. The Register reports that the group's concern centers on how easily customers can leave a platform once they have joined.
The group also takes issue with the tools companies offer people to control their personal data, which it argues do not give users meaningful choices. The Register frames this as a challenge to whether current rules are being applied in practice.
The reporting does not name the specific companies under scrutiny, set out the penalties BEUC wants, or describe any reply from EU regulators. Those details will shape how far the complaint goes.
Background
The European Union has spent several years building rules aimed at large digital platforms. The General Data Protection Regulation, in force since 2018, sets out how companies must collect, use and protect personal information, and gives people rights such as access to their own data. Alongside it, the Digital Markets Act targets firms that hold a dominant position in key online services, often called gatekeepers. Its goals include opening markets to rivals, letting users move between services more easily, and limiting practices that lock people into one ecosystem.
Enforcement is where these laws meet practice. Regulators must judge whether a company's changes are real or only meet the letter of a rule, and that judgment often takes time. Companies typically argue that they have made good-faith adjustments, while critics argue that design choices, confusing menus or repeated prompts can discourage people from using the options they are legally entitled to.
Switching is a central issue. Data portability rights exist on paper, but moving photos, messages, purchase histories or social connections from one service to another can be technically difficult. Network effects also mean a service is only as useful as the friends or customers who use it too. Consumer groups have long argued that these frictions quietly protect incumbents.
Penalties are another point of debate. Fines are meant to deter, but regulators must balance deterrence against proportionality and legal challenge. The outcome of any single case can set a precedent for many others.
Why it matters
The complaint goes to the heart of whether EU digital rules deliver what they promise. If rules are satisfied on paper while users still find it hard to leave a service or understand their data choices, the gap between law and experience widens, and trust in both regulators and companies can erode. For consumers, switching and data control are not abstract legal concepts. They shape whether a person can choose a cheaper, safer or more private alternative, and whether smaller competitors have a realistic chance of attracting users.
The argument also matters beyond Europe. Companies often design a single global product and then adjust it for specific jurisdictions, so decisions made in Brussels can influence settings and policies used by people elsewhere. Regulators in other countries watch EU enforcement closely when shaping their own approaches to competition and privacy.
For the companies involved, the stakes are commercial as well as legal. Penalties, required product changes and public scrutiny can all affect how they build and market services. For rivals, clearer switching rules could open doors that have stayed shut. Whether this complaint leads to meaningful change will depend on what regulators do next, which remains unclear.
What to watch
Watch for a response from EU regulators to BEUC's call, including whether they open or expand investigations and what kinds of penalties they weigh. Clarity on which companies are targeted will matter, as will any detail on the specific switching and data control barriers the group highlights. Industry replies will also be telling: whether firms announce new portability tools, revised consent screens, or defend their current designs. Finally, consider whether future enforcement is judged by how much easier it makes life for users, not only by whether a box has been ticked.
Viewpoints
Commentary from our columns: three angles on this story.
The Rulebook privacy, safety and regulation
A rule that exists only on paper protects people in theory. The central question raised by this complaint is whether compliance is measured by the outcome for users or by the existence of a settings page. Regulators have a clear test available: can an ordinary person leave a service, take their information with them, and make an informed choice about what is collected? If the answer is murky, the rule is not doing its job, however many documents a company files.
Penalties are one tool, but not the only one. Clear standards for what counts as a usable switching process, along with plain-language requirements for data choices, would give companies and regulators firmer footing. Vague obligations invite minimal, legalistic responses, which is exactly what consumer groups are now describing as performance. Specificity is not anti-innovation. It is what tells honest firms where the line sits.
The strongest version of this debate rewards good-faith design rather than punishing every imperfect interface. But good faith has to be demonstrable, and the burden of showing it should rest with the companies that hold the most data.
The User what changes for people who use it
For most people, the phrase switching barriers sounds technical. In practice it means a photo archive that will not export cleanly, a message history trapped inside an app, or a contact list that cannot follow you to a rival service. When those obstacles pile up, staying put is not really a choice. It is simply the path of least resistance, and the company benefits from that inertia.
Data controls have a similar problem. Settings are often spread across menus, described in dense language, or framed so the privacy-friendly option takes more clicks. Consumers who want to limit tracking can end up with a tool that is technically available but hard to use. Groups like BEUC are essentially asking whether that experience counts as meaningful control.
If the complaint leads to change, the everyday difference could be modest but real: clearer export buttons, easier account moves, and privacy choices that appear at the moment they matter. Until then, users can take small steps, such as checking what data a service exports, reviewing app permissions regularly, and keeping copies of important material outside any single platform.
The Skeptic open questions and weak points
It is worth asking what exactly is being alleged, and what evidence would settle the question. Calling large companies' compliance performative is a strong charge. Performance can fairly describe a poorly designed interface, but it can also become a label applied to any change a critic finds insufficient. Open questions remain: which barriers are meant, how they compare with what rivals offer, and whether the problem lies with the companies or with rules that are ambiguous in the first place.
There is also a risk in calling for harsher penalties without a clear standard. Fines that are large but poorly targeted can produce appeals, delays and cosmetic fixes, which is the outcome the consumer group says it wants to avoid. A penalty is only as good as the change it produces.
None of this means the concern is baseless. Switching frictions and confusing data controls are real problems that deserve scrutiny. The skeptical position is simply that the strength of the response should match the strength of the evidence, and readers should wait for specifics before deciding who is performing and who is not.